Desert_Voyager wrote:JD wrote:Desert_Voyager wrote:The middle section of Dolphin Dance was cut from TD vault 4. It was Franke's part that was cut.
How do you know it was Franke's part ?
besides, isnt it more likely that Edgar would not play any parts that involved Franke so he wouldnt get any royalties ?
I remember that Andy (24db) told me, on Pertou's fan forum, which part was Franke's solo and how he would load different sounds for it on each concert and I think it is very unlikely that Edgar would want to perform or release Franke's music since the courtcase aswell, as I said before.
but as Under Water Sunlight was put together as the result of long improv sessions with Froese, Franke and Haslinger (as quoted from a Haslinger interview) then only the band truly know who composed a specific section, whether they allegedly played the section/solo in concerts (which is hard to believe anyway at that time) is another matter.
As for Edgar not wanting to release music with Franke on it ...well how about Antique Dreams, or the DM remixes, Sohoman, Soundmill Navigator,Vault 4" - TD Live in Brighton/UK &
Cleveland/USA 1986 (2004) or the recent releases of concerts in Preston etc
"I have opinions of my own -- strong opinions -- but I don't always agree with them". - George Bush